ALSO YOU CAN LISTEN ON
Welcome to YourForest Podcast, where we explore the interconnections between environmental science, sustainability, and the human connection to nature. In this insightful episode, host Matthew Kristoff is joined by Mike Leahy and Rebecca Quiñonez-Piñón to discuss the fascinating world of Monarch butterflies and the significant conservation efforts underway to ensure their survival.
Mike Leahy serves as the Senior Director for Wildlife Hunting and Fishing Policy at the National Wildlife Federation whereas Rebecca serves as the Senior Scientist at the National Wildlife Federation, where the latter focuses on Monarch butterfly conservation. Both offer their profound insights into these butterflies' scientific and cultural significance, particularly their migratory patterns and habitat needs. From the role of the National Wildlife Federation to individual actions that can contribute to monarch recovery, the conversation covers a broad spectrum of topics.
Key Takeaways:
National Wildlife Federation's role: Mike explains how The National Wildlife Federation plays a key role in wildlife and species conservation across the United States, fostering a diverse membership base that includes hunters, anglers, and wildlife advocates.
The Charisma of Monarch Butterflies: Rebecca discusses the unique characteristics of the Monarch butterfly that make it a subject of both public and scientific interest. The Monarch butterfly's colors and migration practices are not only captivating but also serve as tools for ecological education.
The unique challenges and successes in Monarch butterfly conservation: The discussion delves deep into the various threats that Monarch butterflies face, which include habitat loss, pesticide use, and climate change, particularly focusing on the species’ dependence on milkweed plants for reproduction and survival.
Conservation Challenges: The episode highlights the critical challenges facing monarch populations, including habitat destruction, pesticide use, and climate change.
Community Involvement: Effective strategies for community involvement in monarch conservation are explored to create butterfly-friendly environments. This segment underscores the role of individual and community actions in supporting conservation efforts
Follow the guests on
Sponsors
Notable Quotes:
[00:06:02-00:06:13]Mike Leahy: “We’re the nation's largest conservation organization, and we work on pretty much anything and everything related to wildlife and species conservation.”
[00:11:06-00:13:00]Rebecca Quiñonez-Piñón: “For some reason, the monarch has that amazing ability to embed that memory during your childhood... in Mexico, the monarch is part of the celebration of the Day of the Dead.”
[00:31:09-00:31:22] Matthew Kristoff: “I was reading earlier that it wasn't necessarily that the repopulation wasn't happening, but that there was a lot of mortality along the migration route, more than previous decades.”
Takeaways with Timestamps:
[00:01:08] Introduction of the episode:
Matthew introduces the topic and guests, setting the stage for a detailed discussion on Monarch Conservation. He begins the episode by highlighting the critical ecological role of Monarch butterflies and the urgency of addressing their declining populations. He sets the stage for a discussion on the complexities of conservation efforts and strategies to ensure the survival of this iconic species.[00:04:09] Mike Leahy’s introduction and background:
Mike Leahy discusses his role at the National Wildlife Federation and the organization’s efforts in conservation. He further explains how the Federation’s initiative aligns with its history and commitment to uniting diverse groups toward common conservation goals.[00:07:35] Rebecca Quiñonez-Piñón’s journey to monarch conservation:
Rebecca shares her personal and professional background, before moving forward to her current focus on Monarch butterflies. She elaborates on the charismatic nature of the Monarch butterflies, which not only captures public and scientific interest but also holds a special place in cultural traditions, such as Mexico’s Day of the Dead.[00:10:41] The Charismatic nature of the Monarch butterfly:
Discussion on why Monarch butterflies capture public and scientific attention. The guests explain how the connection many people have with monarchs often begins in childhood, reinforced by their visibility in gardens and their frequent use as educational subjects.[00:27:36] The Importance of habitat and native milkweed:
The discussion details the various threats that Monarch butterflies face, which include habitat loss, pesticide use, and climate change. Strategies to counter this include planting native milkweed plants and maintaining butterfly-friendly habitats to support their life cycles.[00:41:53] Public engagement in conservation:
Exploration of how public actions, like rearing monarchs and planting milkweeds, impact conservation efforts. The conversation points to the power of grassroots actions that can collectively lead to significant impacts on the monarch populations across North America.[01:03:20] Ultimate conservation strategies:
Mike and Rebecca share their ultimate strategies for monarch conservation if resources were truly unlimited. Together, their insights paint a picture of a robust conservation program to ensure that the Monarch butterflies not only survive but thrive in an ever-changing world.[01:06:13] Concluding segment:
In the concluding segment of the podcast, Matthew expresses his appreciation for the insights shared by Mike and Rebecca, noting how their proposed actions for monarch conservation are both practical and achievable. He concludes with a call to action, encouraging listeners to contribute to the conservation of Monarch butterflies, underscoring the cultural and ecological significance of these efforts.
ARTICLE
The Biggest Threats to Monarch Butterflies and How to Protect Them
Monarch butterflies are more than just beautiful insects. They travel thousands of miles each year, connecting ecosystems across North America.
Their bright orange and black wings make them easy to recognize, but their future is uncertain. Habitat loss, pesticides, and climate change have caused their numbers to drop, raising concerns among scientists and conservationists.
To understand what's happening and how to help, experts like Mike Leahy and Dr. Rebeca Quiñonez-Piñón from the National Wildlife Federation (NWF) share their insights.
Mike focuses on wildlife conservation policy, ensuring species like monarchs get the protection they need. Dr. Rebeca specializes in habitat restoration and international efforts to save migratory species.
In this article, we will explore why monarch butterflies matter, the threats they face, and the efforts underway to protect them. We will also discuss the debate over their endangered status and simple ways people can contribute
Why Do Monarch Butterflies Get So Much Attention?
Monarch butterflies stand out for many reasons. Their bright orange and black wings make them easy to recognize.
They travel thousands of miles during migration, and people feel a strong emotional and cultural connection to them. Scientists also study them closely because their decline signals trouble for other pollinators.
A Childhood Connection
Many people first see monarchs as kids. They fly through gardens, rest on flowers, and sometimes even land on curious hands.
Teachers often use monarchs to teach students about nature and life cycles in schools. Watching a caterpillar turn into a butterfly leaves a lasting impression. That early experience helps people care about nature as they grow up.
Deep Cultural Meaning in Mexico
Monarchs are more than just butterflies in Mexico. They arrive every year around November 2, just in time for Día de los Muertos (Day of the Dead).
Many believe these butterflies carry the souls of loved ones who have passed away. Their colors—orange, black, and white—match the decorations used in the celebrations. Monarchs appear in art, altars, and traditions, making them a symbol of remembrance.
A Warning Sign for Nature
Monarchs are important for more than just their beauty. Scientists call them an "indicator species," meaning their health reflects the environment's health.
When monarch numbers drop, it often means other pollinators, like bees and butterflies, are also struggling. Canada has even listed monarchs as endangered because of their rapid decline.
Why Are Monarchs Disappearing?
Monarchs used to gather by the millions in Mexico's Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve. Now, their numbers are falling fast.
The main reasons are:
Habitat loss – Cities, farms, and logging have destroyed the forests where monarchs rest.
Pesticides – Chemicals used on crops kill milkweed, the only plant monarch caterpillars can eat.
Climate change – Extreme weather makes migration harder, affecting food sources and breeding grounds.
Despite these challenges, people are working to protect monarchs. Their beauty, history, and importance make them worth saving.
How Big Is the Monarch Butterflies Overwintering Area?
Monarch butterflies spend the winter in a small region in central Mexico called the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve. This protected area spans thousands of acres, but monarchs only cluster in specific sites within the core zone.
Core Zone: This is where monarchs form dense colonies during winter. Popular locations like El Rosario and Chincua attract visitors who want to see the butterflies in their natural habitat.
Buffer Zone: This surrounds the core zone and helps protect the area from human activity while allowing some land use.
Because monarchs rely on such a small space, any changes—like deforestation, extreme weather, or pollution—could have devastating effects. If their winter habitat disappears, so do the butterflies.
Why Is There Debate About Protecting Monarchs?
Many conservationists believe monarchs should be listed as threatened under the U.S. Endangered Species Act (ESA). This law is supposed to rely on science, but politics and economics often get involved.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service studies species status using scientific data. Experts who reviewed this data agree that monarchs meet the criteria for threatened status. However, some argue over the decision because endangered species protections can affect industries like farming and land development.
What Is the Biggest Threat to Monarch Butterflies?
Monarchs face many challenges, but losing their migration is the most urgent. Their journey from Canada to Mexico covers thousands of miles and takes multiple generations to complete. Several factors are making it harder for them to survive this trip:
Habitat loss – Urban expansion and agriculture destroy their breeding and resting sites.
Pesticides – These chemicals kill monarchs and milkweed, the only plant their caterpillars eat.
Climate change – Unpredictable weather disrupts migration and damages overwintering sites.
Some studies show that about 3% of the eastern monarch population dies during migration each year. That number might not seem high, but when combined with habitat destruction and other pressures, it becomes a serious problem.
What Can People Do to Help?
One of the simplest ways to help monarchs is to stop using pesticides, especially at home. Many people spray chemicals in their gardens without realizing the harm they cause to butterflies and other pollinators.
Choosing native plants instead of non-native ones can also provide monarchs with food and shelter. Small actions like these can make a big difference in giving monarchs a better chance to survive.
How Do Pesticides Harm Monarch Butterflies?
Many people think only insecticides hurt monarchs, but herbicides are just as dangerous. Herbicides kill milkweed, the only plant monarch caterpillars can eat. They also contaminate nectar plants, which adult butterflies rely on for food.
A common mistake is using chemicals to kill dandelions and weeds in yards. These chemicals stay in the soil and plants, harming pollinators that feed on them. Avoiding pesticides—especially at home—can help monarchs and other beneficial insects.
What Do Monarchs Need to Survive?
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has identified key actions to help monarchs recover:
Plant more milkweed and nectar plants – Monarchs need milkweed for egg-laying and nectar plants for food.
Protect their overwintering sites – These locations in Mexico are critical for their survival.
Reduce pesticide use – Chemicals on crops, lawns, and gardens threaten monarchs and their food sources.
Encourage public support – Monarch conservation depends on awareness and action from as many people as possible.
Since monarchs live in different areas throughout the year, people everywhere can help. Even planting a few milkweed plants in a backyard, community space, or balcony makes a difference.
Why Does Milkweed Need to Be Native?
Not all milkweed is good for monarchs. Tropical milkweed, for example, can cause serious problems. It grows year-round in warm areas, leading to higher parasite levels that weaken monarchs. Some research suggests that monarchs raised on non-native milkweed have trouble migrating.
The best way to help is to plant native milkweed. The U.S. has over 70 native milkweed species, and Canada has its own varieties. Choosing the right type ensures monarchs get what they need without unexpected risks.
Should People Raise Monarch Butterflies at Home?
Raising a few monarchs in a classroom or backyard can be a great learning experience. However, large-scale rearing does not help monarch populations. Monarchs raised indoors don't face natural conditions, which can weaken their ability to survive in the wild. Studies show they may struggle with navigation and migration.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service suggests a limit of 250 monarchs per person for captive rearing to prevent harm. Instead of raising butterflies, the best way to help is to create a habitat with native plants and avoid pesticides.
How Can People Get Involved?
One of the easiest ways to help monarchs is to plant milkweed and nectar plants. Programs like Garden for Wildlife by the National Wildlife Federation offer guidance on planting the right species and creating pollinator-friendly spaces. Participants can even certify their gardens as butterfly habitats.
Even small actions—like planting flowers and skipping pesticides—can create safe spaces for monarchs and other pollinators.
Why Do Native Plants Matter for Monarch Butterflies?
A plain green lawn might look nice but does little for wildlife. Monarchs and other pollinators need native plants to survive. Replacing grass with local flowers and grasses creates food, shelter, and breeding spaces for butterflies, bees, and birds.
Milkweed is the most important plant for monarchs, but they also rely on other nectar-rich flowers. Even small changes—like leaving leaves on the ground in fall or making brush piles—can provide shelter for insects. These simple actions help restore lost habitats and reconnect natural spaces.
What Would Happen If Monarch Butterflies Are Listed as a Threatened Species?
Monarchs are currently proposed for listing as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). If this happens, it will increase conservation efforts and funding.
A threatened listing would:
Create a recovery plan – Experts would outline clear steps to help monarchs.
Increase funding and resources – More money would support habitat protection.
Protect key habitats – Breeding, migration, and overwintering sites would get better safeguards.
Encourage public involvement – Governments, businesses, and individuals would work together.
This listing wouldn't mean minor impacts, like hitting a butterfly with a car, would be regulated. The focus would be stopping large-scale threats like habitat destruction and pesticide use.
What Does Successful Monarch Butterflies Recovery Look Like?
A healthy monarch population means:
Enough butterflies to sustain future generations
More protected breeding, migration, and overwintering sites
Less habitat loss and pesticide use
Scientists track monarch numbers by measuring how much land they occupy in winter. A stable eastern population should cover six hectares in Mexico. The western monarch population should reach 500,000 butterflies. Right now, these numbers are far lower.
How Can People Help?
Monarchs need more milkweed and nectar plants across their migration path. Farmers, homeowners, and even city planners can help by planting native species. Roadsides, backyards, and open fields all offer spaces where monarchs can thrive.
Climate change also adds pressure, making habitat protection even more urgent. Conservation efforts must adapt to shifting weather patterns to ensure monarchs survive long-term.
The good news? Monarchs can recover if enough people take action. Planting native milkweed, reducing pesticides, and supporting habitat programs can help keep them flying for generations.
Conclusion
Monarch butterflies are in trouble, but people can help. Planting native milkweed and reducing pesticide use can make a real difference. Even small actions—like creating pollinator-friendly gardens—help restore lost habitats.
Protecting monarchs isn't just about them. Their decline signals problems for other pollinators and the environment. Saving their habitats supports bees, birds, and many other species that depend on the same plants.
Listing monarchs as a threatened species would bring more resources for conservation. However, action at the local level matters just as much. Backyards, parks, and roadsides can all become safe spaces for monarchs.
These butterflies have inspired people for generations. Their long migration is one of nature's great wonders. By planting native flowers, avoiding chemicals, and spreading awareness, people can help keep monarchs flying for years.
FAQs
How long do monarch butterflies live?
Monarch butterflies have short lifespans. Most live about two to six weeks, except for the migratory generation, which can live up to eight months to complete their long journey.
Do monarch butterflies have predators?
Yes, birds, spiders, and some insects prey on monarch butterflies. However, their bright colors warn predators about the toxins they absorb from milkweed, making them less appealing.
Can monarch butterflies recognize their migration route?
Monarch butterflies rely on the sun and Earth's magnetic field to guide their migration. They don't learn the route from other butterflies; instead, they inherit their ancestors' ability to follow it.
What happens if monarch butterflies don't migrate?
Without migration, monarch butterflies struggle to survive extreme weather conditions. Those that don't migrate may face food shortages, temperature stress, and increased disease risks.
Do monarch butterflies sleep?
Monarch butterflies do not sleep like humans, but they enter a resting state at night or in cool weather. They often roost in trees or bushes to conserve energy.